Ecological Guidance of Plant Movement

Studying bean nutation to understand intelligent behavior.

Introduction

In this project we delve into the fascinating world of plant movement and its potential connection to the principles of ecological psychology. Our primary focus is on the helical growth patterns exhibited by climbing bean plants, as they seem to possess the ability to sense nearby objects and adjust their circumnutation accordingly. By measuring these movements and analyzing them through the lens of ‘general rho/tau theory,’ we aim to uncover the underlying mechanisms that guide goal-directed movements in plants. This theory, pioneered and developed by Prof. David N. Lee, seeks to explain how living organisms ecologically navigate their environment. Join us on this exciting journey as we explore the intricacies of plant behavior and its potential implications for ecological psychology.

Why study bean nutation?

Studying the nutation of beans (Phaseolus vulgaris) offers a unique opportunity to explore the possibility of intelligent behavior in plants, particularly in terms of their ability to display flexible behavior when grasping onto a support. Nutation refers to the process by which a plant’s stem, shoot, or tendrils exhibit circular or helical growth patterns as they search for a support to cling to.

Observing bean plants’ nutation patterns could help us understand their capacity for sensing and responding to their environment. As bean plants grow, they continuously explore their surroundings in search of suitable structures to support their upward growth. This behavior may demonstrate a level of sensitivity and adaptability that suggests a form of intelligence, albeit distinct from the kind of intelligence exhibited by animals.

When bean plants come into contact with a support, they have the potential to adjust their growth patterns and coil around it. This flexible behavior could indicate that the plant is able to integrate environmental information and respond accordingly. The capacity of bean plants to modify their nutation patterns based on external stimuli may suggest that they possess some form of basic problem-solving skills, a characteristic often associated with intelligence.

As such, since studying the nutation of beans has the potential to reveal important insights into plant intelligence by exploring their ability to display flexible behavior when grasping onto a support, the MINT Lab researches this question in one of its projects . By investigating how bean plants sense, interact with, and adapt to their environment, we can better understand the underlying mechanisms that drive plant behavior and assess whether it demonstrates intelligence. This knowledge may pave the way for innovative applications in agriculture, environmental conservation, and the development of bio-inspired technologies.

Techniques we use

In this project, we employ a variety of cutting-edge techniques to study bean nutation. Our approach includes creating time-lapse videos of growing bean plants both with and without support, which allows us to visualize and compare their growth patterns over time. Additionally, we utilize image analysis to reconstruct the shoot tip movements in 3D, providing a comprehensive view of plant navigation in its environment. Finally, we apply rho/tau data analysis and hypothesis testing to better understand the underlying mechanisms that guide goal-directed movements in plants, offering valuable insights into their adaptability and responsiveness to environmental cues.

 

Donor

Fundación Seneca

Office of Naval Research – Global (USA)

Duration

Fundación Seneca: 2010-2015

ONR-G: 2018-2023

Lead Investigator

Paco Calvo

Project Gallery

Related News

Exploring Possibilities of Plant Sentience using Time Lapse

Interview with Researchers Paco Calvo and Vicente Raja Innovators in time lapse technology, Brinno interviewed MINT Lab researchers Paco Calvo and Vicente Raja about how to use their technology to study bean nutation!      

Latest Publications

Researchers Currently Involved

Paco Calvo

Paco Calvo

Lab Director

Paco is the Director of the MINT Lab and a Professor of Philosophy of Science at the University of Murcia, Spain.

Aditya Ponkshe

Aditya Ponkshe

Post-Doctoral Researcher

Adi is a Post-Doctoral Researcher who has spearheaded the bean and pea plant experiments.

Vicente Raja

Vicente Raja

Research Fellow

Vicente is a post-doctoral researcher and specializes in Ecological Psychology.

Collaborators Involved

Rogy Holghoomi

Rogy Holghoomi

2018-2019

Rogy came from Urmia University, Iran, to visit us.

Paula L. Silva

Paula L. Silva

Paula is a researcher at the University of Cincinnati, USA.

David N. Lee

David N. Lee

Emeritus Professor

David N. Lee, at the School of Psychology and Neuroscience at the University of Edinburgh, focuses on perception and action, to understand of the visual guidance of movement.

Publications

2021 Calvo P. Rompiendo con el zoocentrismo: Hacia una psicología ecológica vegetal. In Affordances y ciencia cognitiva: Introducción, teoría y aplicaciones, Heras-Escribano, M., Lobo, L. & Vega, J. (eds.), Tecnos.
2020 Raja V, Silva P, Holghoomi R, Calvo P (2020) The Dynamics of Plant Nutation. Scientific Reports 10, 19465.
2017 Calvo, P., Raja, V., & Lee, D. N. Guidance of circumnutation of climbing bean stems: An ecological exploration. BioRxiv, 122358